Last year, the Trump administration’s deportation of international students based on the contents of their speech raised poignant freedom of speech and due process concerns. It also chilled speech among international students who feared deportation. The Stanford Daily newspaper sued; and last August, Northern District of California Judge Noël Wise agreed that the administration’s policy of deporting pro-Palestine and anti-Israel international students violated the First Amendment right of free speech and the Fifth Amendment right of due process. The Trump administration has appealed the ruling. On this week’s episode of The Oath and the Office, John Fugelsang and I invited the Stanford Daily’s Editor-in-Chief, George Porteous, to discuss the ruling and its impact on the newsroom.
The facts under consideration in Stanford Daily Publishing Corporation, et al., v. Marco Rubio, et al. were not in dispute. The Trump administration revoked hundreds of international student visas in 2025. And in court the Trump administration’s stated position was that these visas could be revoked because of the student’s speech. Bluntly, they claim that the First Amendment does not fully apply to non-citizens studying in the U.S.
The policy directly impedes student journalism. George explained that, in the wake of deportations, “we had international students saying they could not participate in what we do here at The Daily—saying that they didn’t want to be sources, that they wanted their names taken down retroactively.”
Daily journalists on student visas also suffered. As George explained, international student journalists “didn’t want to cover certain things and didn’t want to edit certain stories” for fear of reprisal. Much of this fear, George said, “was rooted in so much ambiguity and uncertainty.” Student journalists and their sources had no clear guidelines; whether a certain article or quote might cross the line into dangerous territory is a pure guessing game when no one seems willing to outright define the line itself.
This sort of phenomenon—when state action pressures or indirectly encourages silence—is what courts call chilled speech. At The Daily, it infringed journalists’ power to publish complete and accurate articles; it also abridged international students’ power to share their own stories. As George stated, “a newspaper can only publish what reporters are willing to report, and they can only tell the story if the sources are willing to speak.”
This case, unfortunately, is not an isolated incident. Many of the ways in which this administration chills speech—including by investigating and prosecuting political dissidents—have yet to be successfully challenged. Zooming out, Stanford Daily v. Rubio further drives home a principle that John and I often return to on The Oath and the Office; autocracy, silencing, and corruption—all of these must be actively and passionately opposed in the courts, in the legislature, and in our everyday lives. Otherwise, we signal to those in power that freedom of speech is revocable, rather than a definitive constitutional right.


