In 2021, a Facebook employee released tens of thousands of pages of research documents showing that Facebook knowingly employed algorithms that amplified hate speech, division, and general harm. This “Facebook whistleblower” initiated a tough conversation in the tech and policy realms about how digital products create problems that extend far beyond the screen. That conversation started with a reckoning about the dangers of technology to democracy itself.
The one and only Frances Haugen—the Facebook whistleblower herself—joined John and me on this week’s episode of The Oath and the Office to discuss the longstanding problems with Meta’s social media and why they should concern all American citizens. Frances told her story in The Power of One: How I Found the Strength to Tell the Truth and Why I Blew the Whistle on Facebook, which is now also the basis for the film “The Social Reckoning.”
As Frances explained on The Oath and the Office, her path to blowing the whistle started in the wake of the 2020 presidential election. Facebook’s executives relaxed after the campaigning ended; that meant, Frances said, that “when ‘Stop the Steal’ started exploding on Facebook in December of 2020, there was no one around to be aware that a whole bunch of safety systems that were designed to prevent the weaponization of the platform had broken.” In the lead-up to January 6, dangerous misinformation—amplified in extremist echo chambers—created a ripe environment for lawless violence. Facebook’s response failed to contain the danger.
As Frances’s information revealed, Facebook shares a large portion of the blame for January 6. She argues that Meta executives misled the public about the effectiveness of their AI-driven content moderation; and she claims they also employed an algorithm that amplified extremist content and recommended that users join extremist groups. Facebook’s technological failures created extremist bubbles that echoed misinformation and encouraged violence. The Jan. 6 Insurrection festered and organized in these bubbles. Many of the Jan. 6 rioters, Frances explained, said things like “when I opened Facebook, everything in my feed said that there was a coup going on and that people who cared about their country needed to rise up.”
Facebook’s failures should worry you. If one largely unregulated platform can inspire such widespread mayhem, how do we protect our democracy in the digital age? What about when that platform only conforms to the whims of one unelected CEO—Mark Zuckerberg? These sorts of questions make evident that the need for transparency and regulation in social media is urgent. There are steps that developers can take to make their platforms safer and discourage algorithms from sharing extremist posts or promoting extremist groups. It is clear, however, that the economic and political incentives are not yet there. That’s where Congress comes in. As Frances said, social media has “helped turn a lot of our friends into very mean, angry people.” It’s up to Congress to set standards so that Facebook and Instagram pose less risk to our democracy. That starts with transparency, so the next time Facebook’s safeguards fail, it doesn’t take a whistleblower to hold them accountable.


